The Iona Blog

Maria Steen discusses surrogacy on RTE’s Prime Time

Maria Steen of the Iona Institute discussed the issue of surrogacy on RTE’s Prime Time with David Walsh of the Sims Fertility Clinic on Tuesday in the wake of the High Court’s decision to recognise the biological parents of twins born to a surrogate mother as the legal parents. You can watch the discussion here....

Read more...

How a surrogate mother was pressured to have an abortion

Yesterday’s High Court ruling in favour of a biological mother whose child was born to a surrogate mother and who wanted to be acknowledged as the legal mother was a legal milestone. The case presented surrogacy in a positive light. In fact, surrogacy is an ethical minefield throwing into sharp relief such questions as who...

Read more...

Motherhood presented as an anti-woman institution

This year is the 50th anniversary of The Feminine Mystique, by Betty Friedan, one of the most influential books of the late 20th century and possibly the key text in modern feminism. In the latest edition of the Family in America journal, author Charmaine Crouse Yoest argues that the book launched modern feminism’s war on...

Read more...

Considering a ‘right’ to assisted suicide at the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court is in the midst of considering the issue of assisted suicide, after last month’s High Court ruling upholding Ireland’s ban on the practice was appealed. Yesterday, the court heard from the lawyer from the Irish Human Rights Commission (IHRC), Frank Callanan SC, who argued that the appellant, Marie Fleming, should have the...

Read more...

Talking about abortion to 120 sixth year girls

Last week I was asked by a school to address its transition year and sixth year girls on the topic of abortion. Talking about abortion to a group of 120 17 and 18 year olds struck me as risky business. Would they react against what I had to say, or would they ‘merely’ be bored...

Read more...

Why seven ECHR judges dissented from their colleagues’ ‘Brave New World’ decision

No fewer than seven judges of the European Court of Human Rights issued a partial dissent from the court’s ruling on Tuesday in favour of a lesbian couple where one partner wished to adopt the biological child of the other. The case is called ‘X and others v Austria’ and as was argued in our...

Read more...

Another step towards the Brave New World

The European Court of Human Rights seems to have difficulty treating different situations differently. That much is clear from its ruling in the case of X and Others v. Austria. Instead the court wants to pretend that different situations are the same. Under Austrian law, an unmarried man can seek to adopt his own biological...

Read more...

Economic pressures mean Article 41.2 still needed

Victoria White (pictured) has an excellent piece in today’s Irish Examiner arguing forcefully for the retention of Article 41.2, which deals with women in the home. White makes the excellent-and all too frequently forgotten-point that the article was not designed to keep women in the home, but to protect their rights: “Article 41.2 recognises the...

Read more...

University Times apologises unreservedly to David Quinn

The University Times (a newspaper at Trinity College Dublin) has apologised unreservedly to David Quinn, Director of The Iona Institute for defamatory remarks made about him in its issue of January 5. The apology is carried in the current issue. No damages were sought by David Quinn. The apology is printed below. David Quinn’s reply...

Read more...

More strain on marriage but fewer divorces: why?

Yesterday, the Catholic Church’s marriage counselling agency, Accord, released figures which they say demonstrate that there are increasing strains being place upon marriage. The figures show that the number of people using their marriage counselling services increased and that the number of people reporting financial difficulties, communication issues and stress and anxiety overall had gone...

Read more...