News Roundup

Twelve Irish MEPS vote to make abortion an EU-wide ‘right’

Twelve out of Ireland’s 13 Members of the European Parliament have voted in favour of a non-binding resolution that would enforce abortion across the EU by inserting a ‘right’ to abortion into the Charter of Fundamental Rights and remove the matter from voters and national parliaments.

The resolution was a direct response to the US Supreme Court’s decision in overturning the Roe v Wade case in the United States that enforced a liberal abortion law across all 50 states.

It also calls for full decriminalisation of abortion. It was passed by 371 votes to 161.

One human rights expert, Dr. Adina Portaru, of ADF International in Brussels, said the resolution is “fundamentally inaccurate and misleading“.

“There is no ‘right’ to abortion – on the contrary, Article 2 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union upholds the right to life for everyone”, she said.

The Pro-Life Campaign called the text “extreme in tone” and said if ever implemented, “it would strip away even the most basic protections for unborn children against abortion across the 27 EU member states”.

The Irish MEPs who voted in favour of the resolution were as follows: Clare Daly, Mick Wallace, Luke “Ming” Flanagan, Chris MacManus, Grace O’Sullivan, Ciarán Cuffe, Frances Fitzgerald, Seán Kelly, Maria Walsh, Colm Markey Billy Kelleher and Barry Andrews. Deirdre Cline was not present for the vote.

 

Read more...

Teacher who expressed traditionalist views takes case against disciplinary process

A teacher has brought a High Court challenge to a disciplinary process over social media posts expressing traditional views on social issues such as the importance of having a mother and father.

Gearóid Johnson has been a secondary school teacher for over 26 years and said he has been living as a gay man for over 30 years.

His posts expressed his personal views on the treatment of women under Islam, the need for a mother and father, the binary distinction of male and female, and transgender issues.

Between 2015 and 2016, he was subject to almost daily complaints to his then employer, Dublin ETB, even though he did not mention the college in his posts, or express his views in the classroom.

He said he was wrongly denounced in his former workplace as a ‘homophobe’ ‘racist’ and ‘Islamophobe’ and was subjected to false accusations.

He claims that in late 2017 he was the subject of bullying claims by the school which he denied and which he said were an attempt to punish him by those persons who had complained about his posts.

The ETB ruled against him on the bullying claims and lodged a further complaint against him to the Teaching Council based on his social media postings.

That complaint alleged that Mr Johnson did not appear to be committed to ‘equality’ and ‘inclusion’ or respect diversity arising from gender, sexual orientation, religion, ethnicity and other grounds.

Justice Anthony Barr granted Mr Johnson leave to take his case which will now return to the High Court in October.

Read more...

Missionaries of Charity expelled from Nicaragua

The government of Nicaraguan President Daniel Ortega has expelled 18 Missionaries of Charity from the Central American country.

According to the newspaper El Confidencial, the nuns were taken by the General Directorate of Migration and Immigration and the police from the cities of Managua and Granada, where they had been serving the poor, to the border country of Costa Rica.

Of the 18 sisters, there are seven Indians, two Mexicans, two Filipinos, two Guatemalans, two Nicaraguans, one Spaniard, one Ecuadorian, and one Vietnamese.

The dissolution of the Missionaries of Charity and another 100 NGOs in Nicaragua was approved June 29 by the National Assembly on an “urgent” basis and without any debate.

Read more...

Oireachtas committee recommends ‘compensated surrogacy’

An Oireachtas committee has called for a change in law to facilitate international surrogacy arrangements including a regime of ‘compensated surrogacy’ for women who carry a child to birth on behalf of others. In practice, this can run to thousands of euro and is often little different from commercial surrogacy.

The Special Committee on International Surrogacy released its report yesterday following three months of hearings. Almost all the experts it heard from were in favour of the practice despite the fact that almost no European country recognises it.

Among the recommended, it supported a form of commercial surrogacy whereby the surrogate mother could be “compensated” for legal advice, counselling and medical advice; loss of earnings due to not working; specific dietary requirements or supplements; and payments to cover domestic labour such as housework or childcare (pages 31—32).

Surrogacy agencies and fertility clinics can also be paid for their “professional services”.

One committee member, Independent Senator Sharon Keogan, objected to the conclusions, saying that surrogacy is “harmful” and “exploitative”, and the report “unbalanced”. She said potential witnesses with dissenting views were excluded from hearings.

In a statement, Ms Keogan said there is a power imbalance between the “commissioning parent and the surrogate”.

Read more...

UK Court rules worker unfairly sacked over transgender skepticism

In a closely-watched case, a UK court has ruled that a tax expert, Maya Forstater, should not have been dismissed from her job for believing that men cannot become women.

A tribunal found yesterday that Forstater had faced discrimination and victimisation at work over her views on trans people.

The decision means that Forstater could receive damages in the tens of thousands of pounds after she was wrongly dismissed from her role at the London office of a US think tank.

Forstater’s legal triumph yesterday over the Centre for Global Development came after a higher court ruled last year that her views were legally classed as a “philosophical belief” and protected by equality legislation.

The tax specialist, who has co- founded the campaign group Sex Matters, said that the latest ruling was a victory “for everyone who believes in the importance of truth and free speech”. She added that “we are all free to believe whatever we wish. What we are not free to do is compel others to believe the same thing, to silence those who disagree with us or to force others to deny reality.”

Read more...

New genetic screening lets parents practice eugenics

Advanced genetic screening of embryos created through IVF is allowing parents pick only the healthiest ones to be brought to birth, a practice that amounts to eugenics.

Wired magazine, an American monthly on new technology and culture, says embryonic selection is not new, but past methods were limited to very few chromosomal abnormalities, or the more or less arbitrary method of how one embryo looked against another.

Now, however, companies such as Genomic Prediction are taking this process much further.

Preimplantation genetic testing for polygenic disorders (PGT-P) means “each embryo is given a health score based on the existing mutations in its genes which could potentially one day be life limiting, and the would-be parents are shown how that score compares against the population average. The ranking takes into account the severity of conditions, if shown, as well as the ethnicity of the embryo, since this can also have an impact on disease incidence.”

Genomic Prediction works with around 200 IVF clinics across six continents. But, cofounder, Stephen Hsu’s, innovations have not always been welcomed, even within the academic-scientific community.

In fact, by mid-2020,” the outrage among graduate students at Michigan State University was loud enough to force Hsu out of his position as vice president at the institution”.

Read more...

Murder of Nigerian Christians ignored, says Irish missionary

Ongoing, brutal attacks on Christians in Nigeria, including murder, are being ignored by the Nigerian Government while the Irish, EU and other governments do little to respond.

That’s according to the leader of an Irish missionary society that has worked for years in the country.

Writing in the Irish Times, Sr Kathleen McGarvey of the Missionary Sisters of Our Lady of Apostles says the growing power and influence of Islamist militant groups, as well as the widespread and increasing targeting of Christians in the country, presents an urgent situation that demands attention.

“[The Militants] savagely attack Christian-populated villages, shoot and use machetes to kill all in sight including children, kidnap and demand high ransoms, which even when paid do not assure safe release. They often circulate menacing videos of beheadings, allow public lynching for supposed “blasphemy”, make travel by road and even by rail totally insecure, attack and burn churches and other Christian symbols of identity,” she writes.

Despite this, she says the reality that Christians are being routinely targeted is denied by the Nigerian administration. She adds that this “should not continue to be ignored by Irish, EU and other governments”.

Read more...

Special Oireachtas committee to examine assisted suicide

An Oireachtas special committee to examine the issue of assisted suicide is likely to be established following the completion of a parliamentary committee on international surrogacy, according to the Times, Ireland.

The proposed committee, which will have a reporting deadline of nine months, is expected to be set up after the Dáil’s summer recess.

An Oireachtas spokesman said this week that it was “not possible to give an exact timeframe” for the establishment of the assisted suicide committee.

Last July the Oireachtas justice committee recommended that a special group of TDs and senators be appointed to examine assisted suicide after a failed attempt by Gino Kenny, the People Before Profit-Solidarity TD, to get a ‘Dying with Dignity Bill’ on the statute books.

Read more...

Ireland’s remaining abortion restrictions ‘inhumane’, claims UN official

Ireland’s abortion legislation is “inhumane” and “discriminatory” in its treatment of women with crisis pregnancies, according to a member of the United Nations Human Rights Committee. This is despite it allowing abortion for any reason up to 12 weeks, which is in line with many other European countries. She was echoing complaints from Irish abortion campaigners who want the law to go even further.

The body is examining Ireland’s compliance with the UN’s International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights .

Minister for Equality and Children, Roderic O’Gorman was in Geneva, Switzerland, leading a high-level delegation of senior civil servants to respond to the committee.

Hélène Tigroudja, a member of the body, said the 2018 abortion act placed “very many barriers, both legal and practical” to “safe, legal and non-discriminatory access to abortion”.

She said the three-day wait period was “a disadvantage for women living in rural areas, women in poverty and women experiencing violence [who] simply cannot return several times”.

She also attacked the rule that women carrying a child with a serious disability could access abortion only where the child was likely to die within 28 days of birth: “This is a problem for women who are less well off. They have to continue with their pregnancy … This is inhuman treatment and this is discrimination on the grounds of economic status,” she said.

Read more...

FG TD demands faster revision of sex-ed in primary schools

Fine Gael TD Jennifer Carroll MacNeill has heavily criticised the length of time being taken to change Relationship and Sex Education (RSE) and claimed it could be five years before a new curriculum is rolled out in primary schools. The TD believes RSE should be compulsory.

Education Minister Norma Foley had told Ms Carroll MacNeill in a parliamentary answer last month that work on the curriculum would be completed in early 2025 before being given to the minister.

“A primary curriculum framework that only comes back to the minister in 2025 means no roll-out until when — 2027? That means that any kid born already can be certain not to have it ready for their entry into junior infants,” Ms Carroll MacNeill told the Sunday Independent.

“I think we need more urgency than that. I hope the third strategy publication will put a fire under the department in delivering this. I don’t know what else will.”

“Five years from now is simply too much,” Ms Carroll MacNeill said.

Read more...
The Iona Institute
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

You can adjust all of your cookie settings by navigating the tabs on the left hand side.