News Roundup

Grandmother arrested for prayer walk during lockdown near an abortion clinic

Severe court delays have prevented an elderly member of the UK public from being exonerated of charges she incurred while praying outdoors, in the vicinity of an abortion clinic, during a coronavirus lockdown.

Rosa Lalor received a penalty when on a prayer walk in 2021.

She pled “not guilty” but the case has not moved forward since then.

Rosa had walked and prayed almost every day during the 2021 lockdown as part of the daily exercise permitted by the regulations at the time. She walked near an abortion facility, as she prayed about the issue that was on her mind. She was masked, socially-distanced, alone. She prayed silently, wearing headphones.

When approached by a police officer on 24 February 2021, Lalor was questioned as to why she was outdoors. Lalor answered that she was “walking and praying”. The officer responded that Lalor wasn’t praying in a house of worship, and that she did not have a “reasonable excuse” to be outdoors at that time. The officer claimed that Lalor was there to “protest”. She was arrested, detained in a police car, charged and fined £200 under temporary coronavirus measures.

“The right to express faith in a public space, including silent prayer – is a fundamental right protected in both domestic and international law. Whether under coronavirus regulations or any other law, it is the duty of police to uphold, rather than erode, the rights and freedoms of women like Rosa. Such arrests subject otherwise law-abiding individuals to distressing and drawn-out criminal proceedings, leading to a chilling effect on freedom of expression and religion generally,” said Jeremiah Igunnubole, Legal Counsel for ADF UK, which is supporting Rosa’s case.

Read more...

Abortion after mix-up at New York IVF clinic

A Massachusetts couple has aborted a baby at 6 months and is suing their IVF clinic after discovering that the baby was not related to them. Similar mix-ups of embryos have occurred to Irish couples using commercial surrogacy services abroad, an Oireachtas Committee heard last week.

The unnamed couple in the US already had three children but wanted four. They consulted the Manhattan-based New York Fertility Clinic, went through the standard procedures and the woman became pregnant. However, at about 3 months, a test revealed that the developing embryo was not theirs. Doctors at the clinic said that they thought that the test was wrong, so the couple consulted an independent embryologist who confirmed after amniocentesis that the embryo was unrelated.

The couple then decided to abort the baby because they didn’t want a potential custody battle. Abortions are allowed in New York and Massachusetts up to 24 weeks, but they managed to have the abortion a few days before it would have become illegal.

Read more...

Good Friday pilgrim walk in Dublin, led by Archbishops, to return

For the first time in three years the two Archbishops in Dublin will lead a ‘Walk of Witness’ through Dublin city centre on Good Friday it has been confirmed. The event has been described as a way to express solidarity with Ukrainian refugees and all those who have been “dispossessed and marginalised”.

Since 2019 it has not been possible for the ‘Walk’ to take place with Catholic Archbishop Dermot Farrell and Church of Ireland Archbishop Michael Jackson both attending an empty St Mary’s Pro–Cathedral on Good Friday last year.

The Walk of Witness begins in Christ Church Cathedral at 7pm next Friday with a short time of prayer and reflection. Then the Archbishops, carrying a cross, will lead participants down Dame Street to College Green and through Westmoreland St and O’Connell Street before turning down Talbot Street towards St Mary’s Pro–Cathedral where there will be a short service.

Read more...

Censors ban the word ‘Christ’ from the Internet in China

Censors in China have reportedly told a group of Christians that including the word “Christ” in an internet post breaks new government rules.

Internet firm WeChat, which is estimated to be used by more than eight-out-of-ten people in China, instructed the Early Rain Covenant Church to remove the word.

Andrew Boyd, from the pressure group Release International, has condemned the censorship. He says it shows how severely Christians will be affected by new legislation introduced by the Chinese government.

“WeChat, in responding to that, has pulled down a church’s reference to the word ‘Christ’.

“It considers it to be on a par with pornography, drug dealing and inciting rebellion in China”

The Early Rain Covenant Church had wanted to promote a reading list of Christian books.

Andrew Boyd says one of the books was ‘The Imitation of Christ’ by Thomas à Kempis, which was first published in Medieval Latin in the fifteenth century. But the WeChat censors objected to the word ‘Christ’.

“That’s now considered to be seditious, it appears, in China. That is the most extraordinary form of censorship and it just shows what is actually going on today in China.”

Read more...

Spanish Court rejects commercial surrogacy as ‘exploitation’

Spain’s High Court has ruled that commercial surrogacy constitutes “unacceptable exploitation” of both the child and the biological mother, according to El Pais. A special Oireachtas committee is currently considering how Ireland can facilitate commercial surrogacy overseas.

The case involved a Spanish woman who made a contract with a woman in the Mexican state of Tabasco in 2015 to bear a child with the help of a surrogacy agency.

The court declared that adoption was the better option for protecting “the best interests of the child”.

The judges said that surrogacy treated the baby and the surrogacy “as mere objects, not as persons endowed with the dignity of their condition as human beings and the fundamental rights inherent to that dignity,”

The court was disturbed by the wording of the surrogacy contract. The biological mother had to agree to pass the child immediately after delivery to the commissioning mother, to maintain a consistently nutritious diet, to have frequent ultrasounds, to refrain from sexual intercourse, not to get tattoos, body piercing or cosmetic surgery, not do to do vigorous exercise, and to waive her right to medical confidentiality.

The contract also left in the hands of the commissioning mother the final decision on the life of the surrogate mother if she were to have a life-threatening illness or injury, including brain death.

Read more...

Priest gives up parochial house to Ukrainian family

A parish priest who has turned over his parochial house to a Ukrainian family fleeing the war says being a Christian is “not just praying for something, it is about doing it”.

Fr Brian Griffin, of Castletown parish in Co Laois, opened the doors of the village’s historic Bianconi House – an old coaching inn – to two women and their four children seeking refuge in Ireland after escaping Poltava, near Kharkiv and Dnipro.

Dozens of church properties, private buildings and local authority premises across Ireland are being converted for use as emergency accommodation for Ukrainian refugees.

In the Catholic diocese of Kerry alone, seven presbyteries or parish houses are being offered as accommodation. A large youth centre in the centre of Killarney is already hosting refugees, while the John Mitchels GAA Sports Complex in Tralee has been placed on standby.

Read more...

Pro-life amendments to abortion-exclusion zones bill rejected

A number of amendments designed to curb the worst excesses of a bill setting up exclusion zones around facilities offering abortions were all defeated in the Seanad last week.

Independent Senator Sharon Keogan offered one change that would allow discussion of abortion in nearby facilities such as a coffee shop without thereby incurring a possible criminal prosecution. Her proposal was seconded by Independent NUI Senator Ronan Mullen.

The amendment failed.

Another proposal would have removed prayer and counselling from the list of prohibited actions the Bill proscribes. This too was rejected.

After the seven moderating amendments were rejected, Senator Keogan re-iterated her dismay at the extreme scope of the legislation as it is written. She told the Seanad her only issue was “to protect the right to assembly, the right to protest and our right to prayer in public places”.

She added: “As long as there is breath in me I will defend these rights”.

Read more...

Ireland’s churches rally to support Ukrainian people

Thirty-six Catholic religious congregations in the State have offered 450 rooms in convents, retreat centres, former student accommodation, and houses for Ukrainian refugees.

The Association of Leaders of Missionaries and Religious of Ireland, which represents more than 120 religious congregations, is in talks with the Department of Children and the Irish Refugee Council about its offers.

“We also have had offers to teach English and many religious-run schools have already welcomed Ukrainian children,” said David Rose, secretary general of Amri.

Some congregations in the State are also fundraising or sending aid directly to communities on the Ukrainian border, he said: “We are all praying for peace.”

Read more...

Commercial surrogacy has led to ‘exploitation’, Dáil committee hears

Commercial surrogacy in other countries has resulted in “exploitation” and children being given to parents with whom they had no genetic link, the Department of Justice has warned.

The practice is banned in most countries across the world. Ukraine, Belarus, Russia and a small number of American states allow it. Hundreds of couples from Ireland have flown to countries like Ukraine in order to have children borne for them by Ukrainian women.

Andrew Munro of the Department of Justice told an Oireachtas committee that there are concerns about commercial surrogacy.

“We have seen some very difficult examples in the past where, to be fair, intending parents were trying to do the right thing … a lot of people got exploited by bad actors, where the egg that was purportedly supplied by a purported donor was not the egg. The child given to the intending parents had no genetic link,” Mr Munro said.

He added that there had been cases where the surrogate mother was “spirited away over a border immediately after birth,” or a birth certificate provided by local authorities “named one of the intending fathers as a father despite having no genetic material.”

“And you can see how the surrogate mother and the child and the intending parents were exploited because of weak public administration in a country,” Mr Munro said.

Read more...

Study: Divorce affects children educationally more than death

Parental divorce had a larger impact than parental death on youth educational attainment, according to a new study published by Demographic Research.

Based on data drawn from 17 countries, the study shows that the negative effect of parental divorce on educational attainment appears to be stronger for the children of higher-educated parents. Commenting on the study, Dr Rakib Ehsan said that experiencing divorce may have a stronger impact on these children, as they have more to lose in terms of both financial and non-financial resources.

Meanwhile, lower-educated parents traditionally have relatively low “parental resources” to begin with, meaning the “drop-off” in resources resulting from divorce is less steep — the so-called “floor effect“.

In an article at Unherd, he concludes: “For decades that mainstream has consistently undervalued the negative impacts of divorce. The Demographic Research study confirms that parental divorce can be an incredibly traumatic experience for children. While it is admittedly sensitive territory, there now needs to be a frank national conversation on the risks of marital breakdown and the degree of public respect for marriage as a social institution with moral obligations.”

https://unherd.com/thepost/study-divorce-affects-children-more-than-death/

Read more...