News Roundup

New maternity hospital governance proposal set to go to HSE board – Donnelly

Proposals aimed at ensuring the independence of the National Maternity Hospital (NMH), so it can provide abortions when it moves to the St Vincent’s Hospital campus, will go to the HSE board “very shortly”, the Minister for Health has said. It has been claimed, without concrete evidence, that the Religious Sisters of Charity will somehow stop abortions taking place at the hospital because it will be built on land they have offered at no cost to the State.

Stephen Donnelly said a memo to Government setting out the terms of the legal licence for the proposed hospital would follow “very shortly after that”.

A lot of work had been done in the background over the last six months, the Minister told reporters, with Department of Health officials and other stakeholders poring over legal contracts defining the operational model that will apply at the proposed facility.

These, he added, would “provide Government with absolute assurance that everything there will be just like it is here [in Holles Street], that the only influence will be medical influence, that every service that is provided under law will be provided and that it will be independent”.

Read more...

Law to ban pro-life vigils outside abortion facilities to be introduced

Legislation to enable exclusion zones around facilities administering abortions has been launched by Health Minister Stephen Donnelly. Gardai have previously said existing laws allow them to deal with harassment. No such incidents have been reported and no other EU country has a law like the one Ireland is proposing.

The law is part of the ‘Women’s Health Action Plan 2022’,

Meanwhile, Spanish legislators in the Congress of Deputies have approved legislation that will make offers of assistance, practical support and prayer outside abortion clinics punishable by imprisonment.

The penalty can range from three months to one year in prison or community service from 31 to 80 days. Furthermore, those who are prosecuted could be forbidden from returning to the abortion facilities for up to three years. The Congress of Deputies voted by 204 to 144 in favour of an amendment to the country’s penal code.

The legislation will now move on to the Senate.

Read more...

Church/State agreement to accelerate school patronage transfer

The Catholic church has reached an agreement with the Department of Education which may give fresh impetus to the provision of greater choice in primary education provision for families.

The deal covers 5 towns, as well as the cities of Dublin, Cork, Limerick and Galway, and states that the church’s “Council of Education and relevant Bishops have confirmed their willingness to engage and co-operate fully with the Department in seeking to facilitate a more diverse school patronage in these towns and areas”.

The towns are Arklow, Athlone, Dundalk, Nenagh and Youghal, all of which currently have no multi-denominational primary school provision.

The agreement also states that “no other area is precluded from investigating a change in patronage”.

A Department of Education spokesperson has said guidelines will issue shortly to schools who may be interested in divesting from Catholic to multi-denominational patronage.

Read more...

Doctor administering abortion reversal treatment vindicated

The General Medical Council (GMC) in the UK has dramatically lifted restrictions on an NHS consultant who had been banned from providing emergency support to women in crisis pregnancies, including abortion reversal treatment.

Caseworkers for the GMC dismissed every allegation against Dr Dermot Kearney and concluded that there is no case to answer. They found that the women he had supported had received high-level care and, following expert evidence, that abortion reversal treatment is safe.

Supported by the Christian Legal Centre, Dr Kearney, an experienced Hospital consultant who also provides medical emergency care, had been blocked from providing Abortion Pill Reversal treatment (APR) for up to 18 months in May 2021 by an Interim Orders Tribunal, following a referral from the General Medical Council (GMC).

APR involves administering the natural hormone progesterone to a pregnant woman who wishes to reverse the effects of the first abortion pill, mifepristone.

The ban had followed a spurious complaint involving what the GMC now describe as ‘hearsay’ evidence from MSI Reproductive Choices director, Dr Jonathan Lord.

Dr Lord has also been accused by a woman who had faced a crisis pregnancy of pressurising and ‘scaring’ her into giving evidence against Dr Kearney.

 

Read more...

HSE admits link between ‘telemedicine’ and coercive abortion

The HSE has admitted that women granted medical abortions after a phone consultation may be subject to coercion.

The Govt health agency was responding to a parliamentary question from Carol Nolan TD.

While claiming that remote consultation telemedicine abortion has been a success, the reply also concedes that “meeting the woman in person increases the likelihood of the provider identifying any coercion or domestic abuse”. And in another significant admission, the HSE states that “in-person consultations allow provision of personalised care and allow potential problems to be identified and mitigated.”

Earlier in the week, in a separate reply to Deputy Nolan, the Minister for Health himself completely dodged answering a question about the likelihood that government backed telemedicine ‘home abortions’ are putting women at greater risk of being coerced into having abortions.

A spokesperson for the Pro-Life Campaign called the HSE’s admission “an astonishing development” but one that tracks with what is generally known by both research and anecdotal evidence.

“Peer reviewed research has shown that up to a quarter of all abortions taking place likely involve some form of coercion from the woman’s partner or someone else close to her. Only last week, a man in Worcester, England was charged with a violent physical assault on his 27-year-old girlfriend after she refused to have an abortion”.

Meanwhile, Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín told the Dáil yesterday that the State Claims Agency has received 103 notifications of ‘adverse incidents’ arising from terminations carried out under the new abortion law. It remains to be seen what the precise nature and seriousness of these incidents amount to.

Read more...

Violent suicides soar in countries where doctor-assisted dying is legalised, reveals study

Legal euthanasia and assisted suicide have no impact on the reduction of violent suicides and might in fact increase their prevalence, a new study has shown.

The 35-page analysis in The Journal of Ethics in Mental Health debunks claims by “assisted dying” campaigners that prohibitions against assisting in suicides is driving people to take their lives by their own hands, often horribly.

The report, called “Euthanasia, Assisted Suicide and Suicide Rates in Europe”, found that the introduction of euthanasia and assisted suicide often “is followed by considerable increases in suicide (inclusive of assisted suicide) and in intentional self-initiated death”.

“There is no reduction in non-assisted suicide relative to the most similar non-EAS [euthanasia and assisted suicide] neighbour and, in some cases, there is a relative and/or an absolute increase in non-assisted suicide.”

The study says: “Furthermore, the data from Europe and from the U.S. indicate that it is women who have most been placed at risk of avoidable premature death.”

The peer-reviewed study was carried out by Prof David Jones, the director of the Oxford-based Anscombe Centre for Bioethics.

Professor Jones said that his study represented “further evidence that legalising assisted suicide or euthanasia will result in more people ending their lives prematurely”.

“It will not save lives. It will not help prevent suicide,” he said.

Read more...

NI Secretary to lobby for alternatives to denominational schooling

Ministers are to launch a campaign of “nudging and cajoling” to combat denominational education in Northern Ireland, after figures revealed just 7% of schools officially offered integrated education. Many Catholic parents still opt for Catholic schools which tend to be among the best performing in Northern Ireland.

The Northern Ireland secretary, Brandon Lewis, said he wanted to see an acceleration in the number of schools opting for integrated status, believing it was an important part of the post-conflict journey of healing.

“This was one of the factors that people set out in the Belfast Good Friday agreement [BGFA] itself. We are 23 years on and still … such a small percentage of the population is able to be part of and benefit from integrated education. I think it’s just pretty poor progress,” said Lewis.

“We are in a situation where still, people in Northern Ireland first meet a Protestant or Catholic when they go to work or university. [Segregated education] just isn’t going to ever drive full reconciliation.”

Since its foundation in 1921, Northern Ireland’s education system has largely consisted of state-controlled schools, mainly attended by Protestant pupils, and Catholic maintained schools, almost exclusively attended by Catholics, says the Integrated Education Fund (IEF), a not-for-profit organisation supporting integrated education.

“I do believe in nudging and cajoling. Education is a devolved area, but that doesn’t mean that I don’t have an opinion and we don’t have a right as a co-guarantor and co-signatory of the BGFA to do all we can.”

Read more...

British Education Secretary praises Catholic schools for 175 years of service

The British Secretary for Education recently praised Catholic schools on the occasion of the 175th anniversary of the founding of the Catholic Education Service, a body of the English and Welsh bishops that supports Catholic schools.

Nadhim Zahawi, a Conservative MP, spoke at a meeting with Catholic educators at Parliament recently.

“175 years is a significant achievement, so I just want to thank everyone in the room, and of course colleagues here who are so supportive of this extraordinary human endeavour and recognise the incredible valuable work that you do and have done and continue to on behalf of so many young people and staff in school across our country,” Zahawi said.

“You deserve high praise, since many of your schools serve some of our most diverse and disadvantaged communities where the challenges include reaching out to those families where neither parent may be in work or those for whom English is a second language – as it was for this Secretary of State.”

Zahawi concluded by saying he is “proud to call [the Church] my partner”.

Most Catholic schools in England receive government funding, with the Church covering about 10% of costs and the state providing the rest. CES says this arrangement saves taxpayers “tens of millions of pounds a year.”

Read more...

Half a million march for life in Colombia after court decriminalizes abortion

Across Colombia, around half a million people marched on Sunday to defend the lives of the unborn, rejecting the recent ruling of the Constitutional Court decriminalizing abortion up to six months of pregnancy.

The United for Life platform said that “the rejection [by protestors] of the five judges of the Court who voted for the ruling that allows abortion up to six months, without any limits” was “overwhelming.”

“Their immediate resignation is being demanded and that the ruling be annulled because it goes against Article 11 of the Constitution, international accords and treaties, and the Court’s own jurisprudence,” the group said in a statement.

On Feb.  21, the Constitutional Court of Colombia voted 5-4 that abortion “will only be punishable when performed after the twenty-fourth (24) week of pregnancy and, in any case, this time limit will not apply to the three grounds established in judgment C-355 of 2006,” which are risk to the life of the mother, sexual abuse, or fetal deformity.

Read more...

Divorced and separated individuals to be treated as first-time home buyers

New proposals will treat some divorced and separated people, who no longer have a stake in the family home, as first-time buyers.

Housing Minister Darragh O’Brien said housing designed only for nuclear families does not meet “the reality of the world we live in” and the new measures are designed to recognise how “Ireland has changed”.

Mr O’Brien was speaking on the weekend marking 25 years since divorce was legalised, following a 1995 referendum to lift the constitutional ban on the dissolution of marriages.

Divorced and separated people, after they move out of the family home, can often struggle to raise the 20pc deposit required as second-time buyers while paying high rents.

People who end their marriages later in life can also struggle to be considered for a mortgage at all.

Under new plans, set to come into force from April, people who are divorced or separated will be eligible for the state-backed loan schemes.

It is believed this is the first time Irish government housing policy has specifically referenced divorced and separated people.

Read more...