The Iona Blog

Government Ministers hypocritical on Church and politics

On Saturday, Archbishop Diarmuid Martin responded to recent statements by a couple of senior politicians, Ministers John Gormley and Dermot Ahern, suggesting that religion had no place in political debate.   Minister Gormley said that he “thought we had left the era of Church interference behind” and advised the Church to “concentrate its efforts on...

Read more...

A welcome decision on same-sex marriage by the ECHR

Last week’s ruling that the European Convention on Human Rights does not confer an obligation on signatory states to recognise either same-sex marriage or civil partnerships is a welcome one to say the least. It is doubly welcome because the European Court of Human Rights (part of the Council of Europe) is normally so liberal....

Read more...

Poll shows support for children’s rights referendum is very soft

A poll in The Examiner today seems to indicate that there is clear majority in favour of a children’s rights referendum. It shows that 62 percent of respondents would vote in favour of a referendum with 37 percent undecided and only one percent against. In fact, the poll shows how soft and uncertain the support...

Read more...

Same sex marriage not analogous to inter-racial marriage: author

Here is an interesting article about the claim made by campaigners for same-sex “marriage” that their campaign is analagous to the civil rights struggle in the US. The author, Thomas M Messner, says that the analogy breaks down for a couple of reasons. “Marriage is not fundamental to our “existence” and “survival” merely because it...

Read more...

Fatherhood never more needed, but never more under threat

This article on fathers and fatherhood by sociologist Dr Gordon Finley contains a lot of food for thought. It makes the point that there are now multiple threats to fatherhood, but concentrates on three: male unemployment, divorce, and non-marital childbearing. Male unemployment today is higher than female unemployment and female educational attainment is higher than...

Read more...

Politicians tell Church to ‘know your place’

In the last week, two senior politicians, Justice Minister Dermot Ahern, and Green party leader, John Gormley, have effectively told both the Church, and by extension, religious believers, to ‘know your place’. In an interview with The Irish Times, Minister Ahern reiterated his view that politicians must leave their religion to one side when legislating...

Read more...

Adults’ rights trump children’s concerns in AHR practice, says Irish Times columnist

Last Saturday, Breda O’Brien dealt with the issue of Assisted Human Reproduction (AHR) in her column in the Irish Times. She makes the point that the AHR industry here is completely unregulated here, and that, because children conceived through sperm or egg donation have no right to know who their biological parents are, there is...

Read more...

Why religion will make a comeback

Last Thursday night in conjunction with The Irish Catholic we hosted Dr Eric Kaufmann who addressed an audience of about 120 people on the topic of his latest book, ‘Will the Religious Inherit the Earth?’ Kaufmann (himself on the secular (but moderate) side of the religious/secular divide) believes that predictions of the eventual secularisation of...

Read more...

Waters takes O’Rourke to task over children’s rights poll

Yesterday on this blog Tom O’Gorman attacked Mary O’Rourke for smearing any and all critics of the proposed children’s rights referendum without so much  as pausing to consider their arguments. (So much for reasoned debate). Today John Waters makes much the same point in his Irish Times column. One passage in his column is particularly...

Read more...

O’Rourke smears those with questions on children’s referendum

Fianna Fáil TD Mary O’Rourke, who chaired the Oireachtas committee which produced the proposed wording for the children’s referendum, has slammed possible opponents of the wording as “the forces of old”. It isn’t the first time she has attempted to get her smears in first. Actually, her latest remarks represent a slight dialling down of...

Read more...