News Roundup

Top European Court condemns censorship of religious literature

A religious community prohibited from importing religious literature by officials in Azerbaijan received backing this week from the highest Human Rights authority in Europe.

The community had sought official approval to import religious materials but select texts were rejected as they were deemed by the authorities as ‘detrimental’ to fostering respect between religious communities. The community complained that these restrictions constituted unlawful interference with its members’ freedom of religion and freedom of expression, and violated the prohibition of discrimination. This week, the European Court of Human Rights ruled in their favour.

“Freedom of religion is a fundamental right with which the State authorities should not interfere. It is not the proper role of government agencies to determine whether religious beliefs or the means used to express them are legitimate. It is encouraging to see that the Court has upheld the right to access religious literature and highlighted the effect of this kind of violation on religious minorities,” said Jennifer Lea, Legal Counsel for ADF International.

Read more...

Irish have highest rate of families with three or more children in EU

Ireland has the highest rate of families with three or more children in the EU, a report has found. Despite this, our fertility rate is now below replacement level.

The study found that in 2017, 7 per cent of Irish households had three or more children. This was more than twice the average across the 28 member states, which was 3 per cent.

The report from Eurofound, a European Commission research agency, said that Belgium had the second highest rate, at 5 per cent, while Portugal had the lowest, 1.5 per cent. Belgium has a large immigrant population which may explain the figure there.

The rate of larger families in Ireland is dropping, having been almost 9 per cent of households in 2007. The rate of the decrease was the fastest in the EU over the ten year period.

Read more...

Pro-euthanasia bills advance in Portugal, but negotiations lie ahead

The decriminalisation of euthanasia and assisted suicide is a step closer to becoming a reality in Portugal after lawmakers approved a set of bills last week. Moves are also underway in neighbouring Spain to permit assisted suicide.

Lawmakers in the 230-seat parliament cast their votes on five proposals made by five political parties, including the ruling Socialists, to legalise the practices in certain cases and under strict rules.

All five proposals were approved, with the Socialists receiving 127 votes in favor and the Left Bloc’s bill getting the green light from 124 lawmakers.

The votes came two years after parliament rejected a bill to legalise voluntary euthanasia for terminal patients by a narrow margin.

Outside parliament, hundreds of Portuguese, old and young, protested against the bills.

“I think life is an inviolable asset, human life has an inviolable value, consecrated by our Portuguese constitution – thank God,” 21-year-old protester Francisco Guimaraes told Reuters.

“We must care for life until it comes to its natural end.”

Read more...

Majority of Sinn Fein and DUP voters reject North’s proposed abortion framework

58% of Sinn Fein voters and 54% of DUP voters want the North’s new abortion regime to allow the procedure only when a mother’s life is at risk. That’s according to a new poll organised by the University of Liverpool and Britain’s Economic and Social Research Council. The results indicate a clear rejection of the abortion framework the UK Government wants to impose on the North.

A spokesperson for Right To Life UK, Catherine Robinson, said the polling demonstrates that the Conservative Government has no mandate from the people of Northern Ireland to go any further than what is legally required by the Northern Ireland (Executive Formation etc) Act 2019.

The poll of 2,000 people also showed that only 5% of all voters support introducing abortion through to 24-weeks – which is what the Conservative Government has proposed.

Read more...

Infanticide supporting, Princeton professor has event cancelled over disability stance

An event with Australian philosopher Peter Singer has been cancelled in New Zealand after an outcry over his public stance on the morality of killing some disabled newborns.

Professor of Bioethics at Princeton University, Singer, has previously written that parents should be allowed to euthanise disabled babies if they wish to.

In his 1979 book Practical Ethics, Singer included conditions like Down syndrome, spina bifida and haemophilia among disabilities that make “the child’s life prospects significantly less promising than those of a normal child”. He has argued that parents of children with these conditions should be allowed to end their child’s life.

Singer has argued his views do not apply to adults living with disabilities, but only to newborn infants, who lack “rationality, autonomy and self-consciousness”.

On Wednesday, the venue for his upcoming Auckland event announced they had cancelled their venue hire agreement after “concerns raised by the public and local media”.

“Whilst SkyCity supports the right of free speech, some of the themes promoted by this speaker do not reflect our values of diversity and inclusivity,” the venue told The Guardian.

Read more...

Switzerland legalises assisted suicide in prisons

Prisoners will be allowed to request assisted suicide in Switzerland, prison system officials announced earlier this month.

This follows a request made in 2018 by a convict behind bars for life, which exposed a legal vacuum in a country that has long been at the forefront of pushing euthanasia.

Switzerland’s cantons, which implement prison sentences, have agreed “on the principle that assisted suicide should be possible inside prisons,” the Conference of Cantonal Departments of Justice and Police said.

Euthanasia is generally legal in Switzerland, with the only laws prohibiting assisted suicide being those performed with “selfish motives”. In the year 2014, a total of 752 assisted suicides (330 men, 422 women), compared to 1,029 non-assisted suicides (754 men, 275 women); most of the assisted suicides were of elderly people suffering from a terminal disease.[2]

Euthanasia organisations have been widely used by foreigners, in what critics have termed ‘suicide tourism’. As of 2008, 60% of the total number of suicides assisted by the organisation Dignitas had been Germans.

Read more...

Nigerian priest abducted in new attack

A Catholic priest was kidnapped in Nigeria last Friday.

Fr. Nicholas Oboh of the Diocese of Uromi was abducted by gunmen in the state of Edo in the southwest region of the country.

Local news outlets have also reported that several children were kidnapped at the same time.

The kidnapping is the latest in a series of abductions and killings in Nigeria which have involved Catholics and other Christians; clergy, seminarians, and lay people.

Earlier in the week, suspected Islamist militants in Borno state staged an arson attack which killed 30 people, including a pregnant mother and her baby. The attack also destroyed 18 vehicles filled with food supplies for the region.

Read more...

Burkina Faso church attack leaves 24 dead

Gunmen have killed 24 people and wounded 18 in an attack on a Protestant church in a village in northern Burkina Faso, the regional governor has said.

A group of “armed terrorists” entered Pansi in Yagha province and “attacked the peaceful local population, after having identified them and separated them from non-residents”, Col Salfo Kaboré said.

The incident took place on Sunday during a weekly service, security officials said. “The provisional toll is 24 killed, including the pastor … 18 wounded and individuals who were kidnapped,” Kaboré added.

Burkina Faso is on the frontline of a jihadist insurgency advancing in the Sahel. Since 2015, about 750 people have been killed and about 600,000 people have been forced from their homes.

Christians have become frequent targets in the north of the country.

Read more...

Spanish parliament starts the final process to decriminalise euthanasia

A draft law to decriminalise euthanasia received initial approval last week in the Spanish Parliament. It would allow people who are not terminally ill to avail of assisted suicide. In a vote on whether to allow the bill to proceed in the 350-seat parliament, 203 lawmakers voted in favor, 140 against and two abstained.

It was proposed by the Governing, left-wing coalition led by the PSOE party, and opposed by the Conservative Popular Party, the regional Navarra Suma, and the right-wing Vox.

The Bill, inspired by the Dutch and Belgian model, proposes that those who suffer a serious and incurable or disabling illness, with unbearable suffering could ask for euthanasia. First, the patient and a doctor will have to agree, afterwards a second medical opinion is needed, then the patient will have to confirm his decision two weeks later, and 15 days later it can be made. The process will not last more than a month.

The law would also foresee the creation of a Commission for Control and Evaluation in each region, in addition to a registry of health professionals who opt out as conscientious objectors.

The draft law must now go through the Health Commission, go back again to the Parliament and, finally, to the Senate, a process that could be resolved before summer.

Read more...

Special protection for marriage under fire at Citizens’ Assembly

The constitution’s special protection for marriage came in for criticism at Saturday’s meeting of the Citizens’ Assembly on gender equality with claims made that it excludes the recognition of non-traditional families.

Single mother Adele O’Connor and separated father Dave Saunders, from Tallaght, Dublin, gave personal testimonies on how the Constitution affected their lives.

Ms O’Connor said she was “disappointed in the status of the Constitution” which accords special protection to the family based on marriage. Marriage has arisen as a special institution in almost every part of the world, historically-speaking, because of society’s interest in trying to ensure men and women raise their children together.

Mr Saunders, an unmarried father and CEO of the From Lads to Dads focus group, said he had moved out of his family home 15 years ago after a relationship breakdown. He felt the Constitution had not recognised his or any other separated fathers’ rights.

Paula Fagan, CEO of LGBT Ireland and in a same-sex partnership raising two boys, said that Article 41.3.1 of the Constitution did not recognise her family even though it permits same-sex marriage.

She and her partner Denise “planned our family together and were lucky enough to have our gorgeous boys, who are the centre of our world”.

But Ms Fagan said, “only one of us is legally recognised as a parent”.

“Once there is a donor involved, it is a problem as far as the family is concerned. We ask you to recognise and protect our family by broadening the definition of family.”

The couple can both avail of guardianship rights for the children’s medical care but this entitlement “runs out at 18”. Ms Fagan said the Constitution “needs to recognise, protect and uphold what matters in a family”. But currently it’s “a barrier to recognising our family. Marriage equality didn’t fix this”.

Read more...