News Roundup

UK government claims ‘obligation’ to introduce abortion in North despite Stormont opposition

The UK government has said it remains legally obliged to introduce an extensive abortion regime in to Northern Ireland regardless of a motion passed in the North’s Assembly rejecting the “imposition” of abortion legislation enacted at Westminster.

“While I respect the Assembly’s right to state their position on this, it doesn’t have any bearing on the legal obligations which have been placed on us by parliament,” the Northern Ireland Office (NIO) minister, Robin Walker, told the House of Commons on Thursday.

He was responding to an urgent question from the DUP MP Jeffrey Donaldson, who called on the UK government to withdraw the regulations.

In a statement issued afterwards, Mr Donaldson said the regulations had been “foisted upon Northern Ireland when devolution was in abeyance” and the Assembly had “considered the regulations and rejected them on the basis of their discriminatory approach to unborn babies with non-fatal disabilities.

“We want MPs to be aware that the regulations are not what the majority in Northern Ireland want,” he said. “It is time for the government to withdraw these regulations and allow the Northern Ireland Assembly to deal with the matter.”

Read more...

NHS quietly drops reassurances on safety of hormone blockers for children

The UK’s NHS has quietly changed its advice on the health and safety of certain invasive “treatments” offered to children suffering with gender dysphoria.

Regarding the use of hormone blockers to repress a child’s natural puberty development, the website of the NHS used to say, “The effects of treatment with GnRH [gonadotrophin-releasing hormone] analogues are considered to be fully reversible, so treatment can usually be stopped at any time….”.

However, on May 28th, it was changed to read: “Little is known about the long-term side effects of hormone or puberty blockers in children with gender dysphoria. Although the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) advises this is a physically reversible treatment if stopped, it is not known what the psychological effects may be. It’s also not known whether hormone blockers affect the development of the teenage brain or children’s bones.”

The change, which was effected quietly, was noticed by James Kirkup, the Director of the Social Market Foundation. He asked why the NHS is still using such treatments on children given that they now acknowledge that the long-term effects on the physical and mental health of those children is unknown.

He also asked what are the children and parents who were reassured by the earlier NHS advice supposed to think now.

Read more...

Public religious services to begin three weeks earlier than previously announced

The Taoiseach has announced an accelerated schedule for easing lockdown restrictions which paves the way for a return of public masses by June 29th.

From Monday 8 June when what Leo Varadkar called “Phase 2 plus” commences, up to 25 immediate family and close friends may attend funeral services.

People can attend services at places of worship from the beginning of Phase 3, on June 29th, with physical distancing measures in place. Catholic Archbishop of Dublin, Diarmuid Martin, has welcomed the announcement and said “this will be a consolation to many people and preparations will be intensified to ensure this can be done safely.”

Archbishop of Armagh, Eamon Martin also welcomed the announcement which opens the way for a return to public Mass and the sacraments soon. He said at a meeting of the Catholic Bishops Conference next week, “we will finalise our framework and advice for parishes”.

He had announced last week that the bishops’ had been working on a National Framework Document on reopening churches that would include a helpful checklist for parish priests and Covid19 Parish Support Teams on physical distancing and hygiene. “This will help you evaluate progress made to date and guide any necessary improvements in practice within your parish,” he said.

Meanwhile, the Belgian authorities announced that religious services may resume there from next Monday, June 8th. They are the last country on the continent to announce a return of church services. Up to 100 people will be allowed attend, and strict social distancing of 1.5m plus other precautionary measures must be employed. On July 1st, the numbers allowed congregate will increase to 200 people.

Read more...

Parents complain to Minister over sex education reform plans

The Department of Education received more than 50 complaints from parents and teachers about plans to reform sex education with virtually every single letter opposing the proposed changes.

In response, Education Minister Joe McHugh reacted angrily, saying there appeared to be a campaign of “malicious scaremongering” surrounding his plans to change the RSE curriculum.

In one letter, a student primary school teacher said they were “disgusted and shocked” by the proposals which they said was “completely inappropriate and over-sexualises young children”.

They said they opposed teaching the material and having “my own children taught about things such as porn literacy and self-stimulation at the age of eight and even younger”.

Another person wrote: “There may be people who have no regard for the innocence of the children and it is bound to be too much for them and not easy for the teachers.”

Agriculture Minister Michael Creed forwarded a letter that said: “I have serious concerns about the sexualisation of my children. I as a parent have a right to decide when my child is ready to hear about these matters, not a government pushing an agenda.”

Another parent said they believed planned changes were not being discussed in a transparent manner.

“I have genuine concerns that the proposed RSE changes are intended to sexualise children and generate conflict in accepting their own family values, culture, and gender,” they wrote.

Read more...

Pakistan ‘blasphemy’ death row couple’s plea for freedom

A poor Christian couple from central Pakistan have had their appeal against their death sentence for “blasphemy” delayed again. Shagufta Kausar and her husband Shafqat Emmanuel have spent the last six years in jail waiting for their trial to conclude.

The final hearing at Lahore High Court had been scheduled for Wednesday this week, before it was postponed, with a new date due to be announced.

Their lawyer, Saif ul Malook, who also represented Asia Bibi, another Christian woman who had a death sentence for blasphemy successfully overturned, told the BBC the evidence used to convict the couple was deeply flawed.

But, he warned, that judges can be “fearful” of acquitting suspects, in case they are targeted themselves by extremists. Court proceedings have also slowed in recent weeks as a result of the coronavirus outbreak.

The married couple were convicted in 2014 of sending blasphemous text messages insulting the Prophet Muhammad to a local imam. Blasphemy is punishable by death in Pakistan, and though no-one has ever been executed for it, dozens have been killed by mobs after being accused of the crime.

Shagufta’s brother Joseph, who requested his surname not be published, told the BBC the couple were innocent, and he doubted they were literate enough even to have written the abusive messages. Shagufta worked as a caretaker in a Christian school, whilst her husband Shafqat is partially paralysed.

Read more...

NGOs abandon refugee camps while Irish priest stays

While NGOs have fled refugee camps because of the coronavirus, one Christian charity has moved in to take up the slack.

Dublin priest, Fr William Stuart, helps provide schooling to children of Syrian refuges in the city of Tyre, Lebanon, but he has had to refocus on providing basic food aid as NGOs have abandoned their posts.

The school building he used to use has been closed down so he delivers worksheets directly to children in the refugee camps. His group have also been distributing food aid, and helping families plant gardens beside their tents in the camps.

“The situation is critical, all NGOs are gone. People are starving,” Fr William Stuart has told parishioners in Dalkey, Co Dublin, where he had previously served.

“All the NGOs have gone to ground and are ‘working from home’ with the result that refugees are receiving no aid,” he wrote in a stark message.

He told the Irish Times his group view themselves as frontline people “who don’t have the luxury of ‘working from home’ nor can we abandon the most vulnerable in this most difficult of times. To my disappointment this view is not shared by the NGO sector who have wholescale abandoned ship.”

The most urgent need among the refugees was for food, he said. “With no sign of aid agencies and the body politic only helping the Lebanese, things are not good.”

Read more...

Vatican Museums reopen after Covid-19 lockdown

The Vatican Museums and the Pope’s summer residence of Castel Gandolfo reopened their doors to the public this week.

The reopening coincided with Italy’s gradual easing of the nearly 3-month lockdown, which allows many businesses and activities to restart.

The Vatican Museums are ensuring a very careful balance between safety and health needs and the dynamics of a museum visit, without compromising the essence of such a visit, the Holy See Press Office said..

In keeping with the norms of hygiene and physical distance, visitors to the Museums will be subject to a body temperature check and will be allowed in only with a facemask.

A medical and health team from Italy’s Misericordie volunteer group and the Vatican’s Health and Hygiene Department will ensure every need during the opening hours.

Other important requirements for the reopening of the museums will be revised from time to time as the current emergency situation evolves.

Read more...

UK Supreme Court paves way for funding commercial surrogacy

A recent ruling by the UK Supreme Court has brought the legalisation of commercial surrogacy, and its funding by taxpayers in the United Kingdom, several steps closer. Commercial surrogacy involves paying a large fee to the surrogate mother and is banned by most countries as a form of baby-buying.

On April 1st, the Supreme Court’s since-retired President, Lady Hale, provided the leading Judgment in Whittington Hospital NHS Trust v. XX. This Judgment has, for the first time, legitimised compensation claims against the taxpayer-funded National Health Service (NHS) in order to pursue commercial surrogacy services abroad that are illegal in the UK.

The coronavirus pandemic has so far kept this Judgment off the media radar, but according to Gary Powell, the European Special Consultant to the Center for Bioethics and Culture, California, it represents “an ominous development”.

The court upheld a claim from a woman to pursue four commercial surrogacy pregnancies in California at the expense of the UK taxpayer. The judgment is notable in that commercial surrogacy is illegal in the UK, and two Supreme Court Judges dissented from the Judgment on the grounds that it is against public policy for a court to award damages to enable conduct abroad that is illegal in the UK.

Read more...

Northern Assembly passes motion rejecting abortion for non fatal disabilities

The Northern Irish Assembly passed a motion Tuesday night rejecting a major plank of the North’s new abortion law.

MLA’s from both communities voted 46 to 40 against abortion for non-fatal disabilities, including Down’s syndrome.

The motion also implied a rejection of the whole abortion regime recently imposed by Westminster.

While the vote does not overturn the new law, it does apply pressure on the UK Government to amend or rescind it.

Sinn Fein had also come out against some of the Northern Ireland’s Office’s abortion regulations, prompting criticism from pro-choice groups such as Amnesty International who accused the party of propping up “a dangerous anti-choice agenda”.

The Republican party’s amended motion did not go so far as the one proposed by the DUP and failed to get enough support to pass.

NI’s Both Lives Matter said the vote gives hope that the North’s elected representatives “do not aspire to the extreme abortion regime that pro-choice lobbyists have insisted on”.

Both Lives Matter services advocate Marion Woods said: “Both lives matter before and after birth and so we call on our local Assembly to ensure that women and families who face a prenatal diagnosis of disability are supported during pregnancy and post-birth”.

Eilis Mulroy of the Pro-Life Campaign welcomed the motion saying the result shows what can happen when the political establishment doesn’t censor debate and allows the pro-life side to get a fair hearing. “The heart-breaking personal testimonies of women who regret their abortions and the intervention of people like disability rights campaigner Heidi Crowter all helped influence the outcome”.

She added that Westminster cannot justifiably continue to try and impose abortion on Northern Ireland. “It is clear from the 46:40 vote that this devolved issue should be decided by Northern Ireland’s elected representatives and not the UK parliament.”

Read more...

Limit of one sexual partner is ‘good public health advice’, says Dr Tony Holohan

People should limit themselves to one sexual partner to reduce the spread of Covid-19, chief medical officer Dr Tony Holohan has said.

He was asked at the daily Covid19 briefing yesterday whether he agreed with advice from the Dutch public health team to people in the Netherlands to limit themselves to one partner.

He said “that is good public health advice” as a precaution against the transmission of infections generally.

Dr Holohan said there was no specific advice around Covid-19 regarding intimate contact for people who were in a relationship and lived in different houses.

“We know that is a challenge for people,” he said. “And there are general guidelines which they can refer to on engagements between different households.”

Read more...