The appointment of Jennifer Carroll MacNeill, Fine Gael, as the new Minister for Health has been met with caution by pro-life advocates.
The Pro-Life Campaign noted her unambiguous support for ‘pro-choice’ positions, backing a Yes vote in the 2018 referendum; voting for the euthanasia bill proposed by Gino Kenny in 2021; and, voting with the Government to block foetal pain relief for unborn babies, also in 2021.
In an April 2024 interview with TheJournal.ie Deputy Carroll MacNeill was asked about her views on abortion and a contemporaneous debate being held in the Dáil. She said she found the debate “very difficult” to listen to due to her own “difficult experiences” with pregnancies, including miscarriage. She said, “There really is nothing more intimate than a woman in a maternity hospital, at any stage of her pregnancy, with her baby or her unborn baby.”
The PLC note that, while her position is obviously pro-choice, she does not seem to be in a rush to further liberalise the law.
They also commended her as “a person of substance” willing to engage with the arguments in a more thoughtful way than others.